Your go-to guide for where to eat well in Door County
Whether you’re craving fresh-caught whitefish, wood-fired pizza, a classic Wisconsin supper club, or a gourmet farm-to-table experience, Door County delivers in every season. This peninsula might be known for its scenic shoreline and charming towns, but its culinary scene is just as unforgettable.
We’ve rounded up the best places to enjoy dinner across the county, from waterfront dining in Sister Bay to burger joints in Ellison Bay and everything in between. Whether you’re here for a weekend or all summer, consider this your go-to guide for where to eat well in Door County.
Fine Dining & Upscale Experiences
Alexander’s of Door County – Fish Creek
Elegant seafood, steak, and wine pairings in a relaxed yet refined setting.
Chives Door County – Baileys Harbor
Contemporary dishes, craft cocktails, and a modern space focused on seasonal ingredients.
Barringer’s – Fish Creek
A steakhouse-meets-supper club feel with oysters, fresh fish, and beautifully cooked beef.
The Fireside Restaurant – Ellison Bay
Cozy, candlelit, and creative—perfect for a quiet evening and a rotating seasonal menu.
Waterfront Restaurant – Sister Bay
Upscale lakeside dining with panoramic views and a focus on fresh, local cuisine.
Classic Supper Clubs
Donny’s Glidden Lodge – Sturgeon Bay
Steaks, seafood, and sunsets in a quintessential Wisconsin supper club setting.
Nightingale Supper Club – Sturgeon Bay
One of the oldest supper clubs in the area, with hearty portions and classic cocktails.
The Mill Supper Club – Sturgeon Bay
Prime rib, Friday fish fries, and a true old-school atmosphere.
Sister Bay Bowl – Sister Bay
Family bowling alley by day, comfort food hotspot by night.
The Log Den – Egg Harbor
A giant log cabin with a menu full of steaks, seafood, and supper club favorites.
Casual and Family-Friendly Spots
Wild Tomato Pizza – Fish Creek & Sister Bay
Locally loved for its wood-fired pizzas and casual outdoor dining.
Grasse’s Grill – Sister Bay
Fresh, local comfort food with vegan and gluten-free options.
Julie’s Park Café – Fish Creek
Relaxed diner-style meals with a homey feel and outdoor seating.
Mojo Rosa’s – Egg Harbor
A quirky combo of burgers, tacos, margaritas, and fun.
Not Licked Yet – Fish Creek
Known for frozen custard, but their savory menu makes a great family dinner option.
Waterfront Dining Destinations
Harbor Fish Market & Grille – Baileys Harbor
Lake views, lobster boils, and seafood done right.
Sonny’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria – Sturgeon Bay
Casual Italian fare right on the canal.
Old Post Office Restaurant – Ephraim
Home of the famous Door County fish boil.
Waterfront Mary’s – Sturgeon Bay
Relaxed beachy vibe with sandwiches, fish, and drinks.
Boathouse on the Bay – Sister Bay
One of the best sunset views in the county, plus seafood, burgers, and cocktails.
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites
Northern Grill & Pub – Sister Bay
This family-owned restaurant is known for its hand-tossed pizzas, hearty pastas, and signature Cherry Bomb Cocktails.
Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant – Sister Bay
Yes, the one with goats on the roof—and Swedish meatballs worth the hype.
Trixie’s – Ephraim
A tiny, farm-to-table wine bar with serious flair.
Door County Creamery – Sister Bay
Mediterranean-inspired menu plus house-made goat cheese.
Roots Inn & Kitchen – Sister Bay
Creative vegetarian-forward comfort food in a cozy inn.
White Gull Inn – Fish Creek
Fish boils, cherry-stuffed French toast, and cozy charm.
For Wine Lovers and Foodies
Wickman House – Ellison Bay
Farm-to-table dining, creative cocktails, and a beautiful historic home setting.
CHOP – Sister Bay
Modern steakhouse with great service and a deep wine list.
Thyme Cuisine – Sister Bay
Creative plates and curated wine in a relaxed space.
Kettle Black Fish Creek – Fish Creek
Fresh, inventive cuisine with a globally inspired twist.
The English Inn – Fish Creek
A cozy supper club with surf-and-turf options in a classic English setting.
Burgers, BBQ & Pub Food
AC Tap – Baileys Harbor
Open late, no-frills, always good.
Husby’s Food & Spirits – Sister Bay
Lively, casual, and full of comfort food.
Casey’s BBQ & Smokehouse – Egg Harbor
Smoked ribs, pulled pork, and all the fixings.
Coyote Roadhouse – Baileys Harbor
Lake views and killer burgers.
The Blue Ox – Baileys Harbor
Rustic dive bar serving up surprisingly good grub.
International Flavors
Mr. Helsinki Restaurant & Wine Bar – Fish Creek
Global flavors, sushi, and small plates.
Chef’s Hat Café – Ephraim
American food with international flair.
Mediterranean Bay Café – Sister Bay
Fresh seafood and vegetables inspired by the Mediterranean.
Bluefront Café – Sturgeon Bay
Globally inspired comfort food in a laid-back space.
Wildflower Café – Sister Bay
Organic, vegetarian-friendly, globally influenced dining.
Vegetarian & Vegan Friendly
Heirloom Café & Provisions – Baileys Harbor
Bright, fresh, locally sourced dishes.
The Cookery – Fish Creek
Plenty of veggie-forward options with a view.
White Gull Inn – Fish Creek
Traditional favorites with solid vegetarian selections.
Roots Inn & Kitchen – Sister Bay
(Yes, again—it’s that good!)
Grasse’s Grill – Sister Bay
Tons of vegetarian options and a creative, seasonal menu.
If you’re planning your next Door County vacation or just looking for tonight’s dinner inspiration, this guide will help you discover unforgettable flavors in one of Wisconsin’s most beloved destinations.
For a complete list of Door County restaurants, check out the Door County Directory.
