Where to Satisfy Your Cherry Craving in the Heart of Cherry Country
Door County and cherries go hand in hand. Every summer, visitors flock to this beautiful peninsula not just for the coastline and charming towns, but for the unforgettable flavor of locally grown cherries. Whether you prefer yours in a slice of pie, spooned over ice cream, or baked into fresh pastries, cherry desserts are more than a treat here, they’re a tradition.
As one of the largest cherry-producing regions in the country, Door County has perfected the art of showcasing this vibrant fruit. And while the cherry harvest typically peaks in mid to late July, cherry desserts are available nearly year-round thanks to preserves, pie fillings, and frozen stock. If you’re planning a trip to Door County, make sure to save room for dessert, because these local bakeries, cafés, markets, and restaurants are serving up the best cherry sweets in the region.
Sweetie Pies in Fish Creek
If your heart is set on pie, there’s no better place to start than Sweetie Pies in Fish Creek. Nestled in a little red house along Highway 42, this beloved bakery is known for its flaky crusts and generous fillings. Their cherry pie is rich, tart, and perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness. You can enjoy a slice on-site or take a whole pie to-go, and they even offer frozen pies you can bake at home. The smell alone when you walk through the door is worth the visit.
Sweetie Pies (Fish Creek): sweetiepiesdoorcounty.com
Seaquist Orchards Farm Market in Sister Bay
This family-run orchard is a staple in Door County and offers everything from fresh fruit to canned goods and baked treats. Their cherry pie is a best-seller, but the real gem is their cherry strudel. Layers of delicate pastry are filled with sweet-tart cherries and topped with just the right touch of glaze. For something a little more casual, grab one of their cherry donuts or a cherry turnover. The farm market also stocks cherry salsa, cherry butter, and dried cherries, perfect for snacking or bringing a little Door County flavor home with you.
Seaquist Orchards Farm Market (Sister Bay): seaquistorchards.com
Door County Creamery in Sister Bay
For a refreshing twist on cherry desserts, stop by Door County Creamery. Known primarily for their artisan goat cheeses and locally made gelato, this charming spot has perfected the art of balancing fruit and cream. Their cherry goat milk gelato is subtly sweet, incredibly smooth, and bursting with natural cherry flavor. It’s a perfect stop on a warm day when you want something indulgent yet light.
Door County Creamery (Sister Bay): doorcountycreamery.com
Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard in Fish Creek
This riverside custard stand has been a summer tradition for generations. While their frozen custard is excellent in any form, their cherry sundaes and shakes stand out. Made with local cherry topping over thick vanilla custard, the combination is both classic and crave-worthy. The atmosphere here is just as charming as the desserts, with a little bridge, wooded setting, and a koi pond that kids love to explore.
Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard (Fish Creek): notlickedyet.com
Door County Bakery in Sister Bay
Door County Bakery is known far and wide for its signature Corsica Loaf, but don’t skip the sweet side of their menu. Their cherry coffee cake is a standout, combining tart cherries with layers of buttery crumb and a hint of almond flavor. It pairs beautifully with a cup of strong coffee and is the kind of treat that feels both rustic and luxurious at the same time. While the bakery does offer seasonal specials, you can usually find something cherry-based no matter what time of year you visit.
Door County Bakery (Sister Bay): doorcountybakery.com
Wilson’s Restaurant and Ice Cream Parlor in Ephraim
Step back in time at Wilson’s, an old-fashioned soda fountain and diner right on the water in Ephraim. Known for its nostalgia as much as its ice cream, Wilson’s offers a cherry pie à la mode that hits all the right notes. The warm pie, cold vanilla ice cream, and cherry topping come together in a way that’s delightfully old-school. You can also order a cherry phosphate or a cherry soda for an extra splash of fun.
Wilson’s Restaurant and Ice Cream Parlor (Ephraim): wilsonsicecream.com
Wood Orchard Market near Egg Harbor
Located just outside Egg Harbor, Wood Orchard Market is a must-visit for cherry lovers. Their cherry strudel sticks are the perfect snack to enjoy on the go. They also offer jars of cherry pie filling, cherry jam, and an incredible cherry salsa. If you’re lucky, you’ll catch their cherry muffins or cherry crumble bars fresh out of the oven. Everything here is made with cherries from their own orchard, so the flavor is as local as it gets.
Wood Orchard Market (Egg Harbor): woodorchardmarket.com
Scaturo’s Baking Co. and Café in Sturgeon Bay
A bit farther south in Sturgeon Bay, Scaturo’s is a favorite for locals and visitors alike. Their bakery case is always stocked with tempting items, and cherry fans will find plenty to love. Cherry kolaches, cherry tarts, and cherry bread pudding often make appearances, and they’re not shy about loading up on the fruit. If you’re visiting for breakfast or brunch, consider ordering their cherry-stuffed French toast—it’s exactly as indulgent as it sounds.
Scaturo’s Baking Co. and Café (Sturgeon Bay): scaturos.com
Renard’s Cheese in Sturgeon Bay
Though known for cheese, Renard’s also stocks a well-curated selection of cherry goodies in their specialty foods section. From cherry cheese curds to cherry dessert sauces and chocolate-covered dried cherries, it’s an ideal place to stock up on gifts or road trip snacks. And yes, they carry cherry pies too, along with cherry preserves made just a few miles down the road.
Renard’s Cheese (Sturgeon Bay): renardscheese.com
Pink Bakery in Egg Harbor
This cheerful and colorful bakery is relatively new on the Door County dessert scene but has quickly become a favorite. Known for creative cupcakes and bold flavors, Pink Bakery often features cherry-themed treats in their seasonal rotation. Cherry cupcakes, cherry brownies, and even cherry cheesecake bars have made appearances. The aesthetic here is modern and playful, but the flavors are deeply rooted in Door County tradition.
Pink Bakery (Egg Harbor): pinkbakerydc.com
Cherry season might peak in summer, but Door County’s love affair with this fruit lasts all year.
Whether you’re indulging in a warm slice of pie, savoring a cherry-filled pastry, or cooling off with cherry custard, the county offers countless ways to enjoy its most iconic flavor.
